13/12/2009

Bellamy red card unjust and potentially costly

Most football fans will tell you that the luck tends to go against their side regularly. In reality, it probably doesn't, and by rights it can't do for all, but at least two decisions yesterday were extremely questionable, and though we can't say with any real certainty, we'd have probably fancied our chances more had we neither been reduced to ten men or gone behind, though of late chasing games has tended to make us play.

My honest opinion is that we're no more hard done by than anyone else. I don't believe certain clubs get more go their way or that we're victimised by anybody. Most of the calls that have gone against us of late should have done; the penalties conceded against Burnley, Birmingham and Hull, Zabaleta's second booking at Wigan, the foul which led to the opener at Anfield, and going further back, the three-match ban for the Adebayor incident against Arsenal.

The decision to send Craig Bellamy off yesterday, however, really can't be excused. Clattenberg, one of the better referees in England, in my opinion, has made a monumental error and would best be advised admitting as much. The fact that officials make mistakes isn't nearly as annoying as their hard-faced attitude afterwards. We all slip up, but supporters would be more liable to forgive should hands be held up.

Judging the incident from any one of the number of angles available can surely only leave people certain that there was contact, and Bellamy's lack of theatrics afterwards only supports his case. As things stand, in the eyes of idiots at least, the player is being wrongly labelled a cheat, and is being roundly discussed, contrast that to the lack of a mention of a dive by a certain ginger-bearded Scouser and the conspiracy theories might not look all that far-fetched.

It's probably worth pointing out the distinct lack of outrage, even coverage, when an England international is accused of simulation, compared to a foreign player, particularly someone non-British. For all that the likes of Eduardo and Drogba have rightly been accused of cheating and should have been banned, the most frequent diver in English football, Liverpool's Steven Gerrard, gets away with it week in, week out, purely on reputation.

I sincerely hope the club appeals the decision if possible. Were it not so puzzling i'd advocate we take it on the chin and move on, but we face the prospect of losing perhaps our most important player this season for an extremely difficult game midweek. As it goes, that trip is to White Hart Lane, a ground at which debatable decisions have cost us during our last two visits; a late penalty last season and a handled opener the year before. Let's hope the officials that night are a bit more reliable than Clattenerg & Co.

6 comments:

  1. i admire your restraint. Clattenburg was a compete a***hole - he gave a blatantly offside goal for Bolton's first, and then sent Bellamy off because of his reputation? people say luck evens out over the season - where is our luck? 4 pens against, none given for us, SWP v wigan - ADE v hull, we have had no luck whatsoever. On a level playing field, this City side will be a real force this season - our time will come whether or not Bellamy's red is rescinded - COME ON CITY

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yellow cards cannot be appealed against - only straight reds. End of story. Nothing to do with justice, but when has justice ever got in the way of anything?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Could someone clarify whether or not the refs get the opportunity to speak up afterwards or are they not allowed to comment? Motd used to occasionally interview them but I haven't seen that for a while and I have never read comments in the paper. Maybe we'd get more apologies and explanations if they had a medium to communicate through every week.

    ReplyDelete
  4. "Yellow cards cannot be appealed against - only straight reds".

    Aye, think you're right there actually. Real shame, though. At best perhaps we can hope Clattenberg gets a couple of weeks in the Championship, but i wouldn't bank on it.

    As for the rule itself, well, bit of a nonsense really, eh?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I don't think Bellamy's red card will affect us in anyway. He wouldn't have played on wednesday even without the red card since Bellamy's knees will not permit two games in a week.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well the fa have repealed yellows in the past! and we know they seem to ignore most rules when it comes to city!

    Clattenburg, one of the better ones? i cant agree, he, lest we forget was the one who made a complete hash of the liverpool derby. I think the whole officating was poor, the linesman ignored the blatant offside for the 1st goal! Allowing robinson to get away with several fouls, which led to bellamys 1st card. The red card was a farce, 40 yards away, and he could spot a dive. Thats not right! He made a guess, and was more than happy to send bellamy off,without reason. I think hughes was right to question the integrity of the man, discussing players at half time should lead to severe disciplinary actions.

    I'm pretty sure he's bent, with his links to far eastern betting syndicates. He was suspended for this, with his failing business. He was only allowed back through inconclusive evidence. Corruption is rife in football and it's only a matter of time before someone lifts the lid! Rob Styles quickly retired, because he was forced out. Mike dean forget to mention his work for a betting syndicate!

    ReplyDelete